Evaluation of a New Inverse, Globally Convex Treatment Planning System Algorithm for Gamma Knife Radiation Surgery Within a Prospective Trial: Advantages and Disadvantages in Practical Application

Abstract: 

Purpose: A new inverse planning software called IntuitivePlan (IP) based on a global convex optimization algorithm was adopted for the Gamma Knife radiation surgery. We investigated IP's suitability for daily clinical use and its applicability for different cerebral entities.

Methods and Materials: For 230 target volumes, IP was tested in a prospective trial. The computed treatment plans were compared with conventional expert preplans, which included forward planning by the expert and local internal optimization. Based on the same dose constraints, we used the default settings for the inverse calculation of the treatment plans. Plan quality metrics such as the Paddick conformity index were compared for both planning techniques with additional subdivisions into the 3 selectable IP planning strategies and different entity groups.

Results: IP calculated treatment plans of quality similar to that of preplans created by expert planners. Some plan quality metrics, especially those related to conformity and dose gradient, attained statistically significantly higher scores combined with high coverage for the inversely generated plans except for the selectivity optimizing strategy. Normal brain volume receiving 10 Gy or 12 Gy or higher (V10 Gy or V12 Gy) did not show significant differences for the coverage optimizing strategies. The IP software demonstrated significantly shorter planning times versus manual planning as well as greater numbers of isocenters, often associated with longer treatment times. In terms of total time, these differences almost balanced out again.

Conclusions: Our results suggest that IP is advantageous for complex tumors. We observed general clinical significance for conformity and superiority for the selectivity optimizing strategy. In addition, the high-quality calculation from IP enables novices in the profession to achieve pre-treatment plans of a quality similar to that of expert planners. IP allows for optimizing the sparing of surrounding tissue and conformity for benign tumors within a short time. Thus, IP forms a solid basis for further planning on the treatment day.

To the paper:  
Advances in Radiation Oncology (2022) 7 101006 

Our other publications on the subject of radiotherapy can be found on the corresponding list of publications.